Skip to main content

Review: The Past as Present: Forging Contemporary Identities Through History

The Past as Present: Forging Contemporary Identities Through History The Past as Present: Forging Contemporary Identities Through History by Romila Thapar
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Loved the details. Highly informative even if some of her ideas have been contested often times. Romila Thapar is without doubt one of the best Historians alive in India today. Her characteristic narrative style with adequate focus on analyzing an issue from all corners, makes one think strongly about the believes they have had since as long as they can remember. How can one say if the tradition that they have been following since decades and centuries isn't something that originally begun with those ideas mind and isn't were simple tactics to gain wealth and suppress the enemies; when the sources themselves that tell us the history of these practices can be found to not withhold under scutiny. The history of India, it seems, is as multi-faceted and ever changing as are the people and it's languages in the contemporary world, a fact that's often overlooked when the subject is taught in the schools.

The author talks on all these and much more in this phenomenal book. I specifically found the chapters on the emancipation of the Women in ancient and mediaeval India, highly illuminating. As Yuval Nova Harari said in his masterful essays, "Women have been the single most underprivileged and ill-treated section of the society throughtout the history all the major cultures of the world." In her book, Thapar emphasizes how some accounts usually cited as an example of possibly equal status of women, like that of the scholar Gargi in the upnishads, are but some lone elite cases that don't represent the majority classes. She goes on to say that instead stories about what went around with the suppressed Dasis are not at all present in the ancient literatures. Practises such as Sati, that were prevalent in much of India until very recently in historical terms, in fact show that the Women were often treated rather as a commodity and were moved out of the way when their targeted purpose is finished or when they appear to pose a threat to the Men's share of wealth.

"The Past as Present" is a thought provoking book, full of insightful essays. Highly recommended as an illuminating take on some of the most controvertial topics in current Indian Geopolitical History. To what extend you agree with the ideas dealt with herein is totally upto you, but I would rather be taken back if the book doesn't make to atleast think a little deeper about what you know as your culture and your past.

View all my reviews
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Breakfast at Tiffany's

Breakfast at Tiffany's by Truman Capote My rating: 3 of 5 stars Hmm... hard to say whether or not I like it. The story is fine. The protagonist is spectacular. And yet, I cannot seem to whole-heartedly be fond of the novella. Parts of the story are fascinating, for instance, Holly Golightly's apparent unreserve with the budding writer narrator. I also like the opening scene which introduces the mystery of where our heroine can be at the moment. The scene brings the reader into the story and somehow or the other, we are entrapped the fast-paced New York of 1940. I would recommend the book as a tranquil read. However, honestly, with the impeccable performance by Audrey, the film version brings forth Holly's persona a tad bit more effectily. The book is outstanding, no doubt, but couple it with the movie session post reading and there you have it - " a top banana in the shock department". View all my reviews
Post a Comment
Read more

Why I write?

Initially I wanted to title this post,  On writing Diaries , however this thought-provoking question is far better. Although it may take me a long time to be an author per se, more or less, I have been a continuous writer since my seventh grade. What started with jotting down non-sense farce on daily routines during the middle school years, has now grown into some fierce rhetoric on vast ranging topics important to me in general. So, what is it about writing that I like so much? Unlike most of my friends, what has made me go on for so long now? Why do I write? And why do I plan to write more vigorously, more persuasively and more indiscriminately than ever in the coming future? Well, there isn't any plain simple answer to these. I write because I like to write. I write because it gives reality to all of these thoughts inside my head which couldn't find an route through the tongue. I write because it often makes me feel good. I write because I find this the best way to convey my...
2 comments
Read more

An Ordinary Day

To a majority of us, it is a known fact that some days are actually longer than a day. The day in question, however, wasn't. It was in fact meant to be one of the driest and the most barren of the days. The kind of a day one mostly spends snug on the bed with the largest exertion afforded to the limbs being the quiet finger pressings on a touch screen. And yet, looking back now, the singular chain of events from that day, though ordinary in themselves, assume such a perplexing proportion when taken together, that the day has remained so unequivocally imprinted in my mind. At that time I was working as a JSPS Post-Doctoral fellow in the Department of Physics at the University of Tokyo. I had come to Japan from India as a Master’s student about six years prior and had been living in Tokyo since then. Following the PhD degree, owing to my fascination with the city and in order to satisfactorily sum up my current research, I had chosen to continue at the ...
Post a Comment
Read more